Day to Day Assessment in the Reading Workshop
I had long stretches in the car this weekend as we drove my son for a college visit near Washington D.C. What was supposed to be a 7 hour drive from Columbus, Ohio, turned into a 10 hour drive as we came to a standstill several times and crawled along in traffic. I really didn’t mind though, because it gave me the opportunity to get some reading done.
One of the books that I was looking forward to reading was Franki Sibberson and Karen Szymusiak’s Day to Day Assessment in the Reading Workshop. When it was published in 2008, I was up to eyeballs in learning first grade curriculum after being in the intermediate grades for over 15 years. As much as I wanted to read it then, I just couldn’t add one more thing to my already saturated brain.
Now, as I’m preparing to teach to third grade, I am more than ready to step back into the role of teaching transitional readers and this book was the perfect way to reacquaint myself with these students. I have to be honest, as I read, it was like putting on an old pair of slippers…it just felt right…comfortable and familiar. First of all, I love the authors’ philosophy…their instruction is based on their response to the needs of their students, not on a list of standards that can be checked off (although they do keep the standards in mind when planning instruction.) The introduction opens with the following quote which says it all, “Let us, with the ancient doctors, vow first to do no harm, and promise to resist measures that deprive children of their natural enthusiasm and exuberance as learners, their impulse to ask questions, to figure things out, to wonder, to express, to investigate, to construct, to imagine. Let us commit to a quiet contemplation of the idea that children are universally passionate learners.” ~Robert L. Fried, The Passionate Learner (2002) Isn’t that what we all want; passionate learners who are excited to come to school, who are inquisitive, and thirsty for knowledge?
The book begins by stressing the importance of building an intellectual community where members come together to learn and everyone grows because they are a community of learners who support each other. Building a strong community so important during the first 6 weeks of school. It sets the tone for the rest of the school year. Franki uses several different means to informally assess her students (reading inventories, status of the class, reading logs, and written responses to read alouds to name a few) during this time. She wants her students to know that she values them as learners and readers before she begins to formally assess them. It is also during this time that she sets up routines that let her students know that her room is a place where it is safe to take risks and all thinking is honored.
Each chapter focuses on one aspect of the reading workshop…independent reading, read aloud, whole class mini-lessons, small groups, and individual conferences. Within each of these chapters, the authors give examples of assessments (both informal and formal), book ideas, questions to ponder, reflection sheets, recording forms, and student samples. One of the (many) things I like about this book is that it doesn’t focus on what the most gifted readers are doing. Franki and Karen are very honest in their portrayal of students that span the continuum we all have in our classrooms. They use student misunderstandings as an opportunity to determine what needs to be taught next. They hold back from informing a student that her thinking is incorrect, but instead, use this knowledge to plan for instruction.
So, my copy of the book is peppered with colored sticky tabs: pink for quotes I want to remember, yellow for ideas for charts, mini-lessons, and forms, blue for questions to think about, and orange for book ideas. I have scribbled some book ideas in the back of the book…books I want to review before school starts and possibly add to my classroom library: Katie Kazoo, Ivy and Bean, Clementine, and How to Steal a Dog just to name a few. Tomorrow I will go down into my basement to delve into the tubs of books I have from teaching 4th grade to see what I can use in 3rd. I can’t wait to dive into my new classroom to create spaces that will invite conversations among individuals, small groups and the whole class. And another bonus? I will be working with some of the same kids I had in first grade 2 years ago. I already know them as learners and we will be off to a great start!



I packed up my classroom yesterday, getting ready to make the move from first grade to third grade, with mixed emotions. I’m excited to be moving into new, yet familiar territory. Third graders are not so different from fourth graders, with whom I spent 12 years of my life. I can’t wait to work with some of my students that I had 2 years ago; oh the stories I had with that class! It was one of those years that if you didn’t laugh, you would cry.
So, third grade here I come! More changes are in my future that will take me who knows where: I have a new group of wonderful women to work with, my family is hosting a foreign exchange student from India this school year, and I’m taking the first steps in beginning a doctoral program.
